You did your first proper leg session on Monday. It is now Wednesday, and sitting on the toilet has become a planned operation. You are due to train again today. Should you?
Most of the time, the answer is yes, with some adjustments. This guide shows how to decide, along with the signs that mean you should not.
What is that soreness?
The usual soreness that arrives after exercise is called delayed onset muscle soreness, or DOMS. It is delayed by nature, typically peaking 48 to 72 hours afterwards, which is why Wednesday can feel worse than Tuesday. A review in Sports Medicine describes symptoms ranging from muscle tenderness to severe pain. It is most common when people return to training after a break, or try a new type of exercise. Eccentric work, where a muscle lengthens under load, like the lowering part of a squat, causes it more often and more severely than other types of muscle action.
The exact cause is not settled. The review lists six theories, and says a combination of two or more is likely, including muscle damage and inflammation. The old idea that it is just lactic acid is too simple.
A quick decision guide
| How you feel | What to do today |
|---|---|
| Mildly stiff, gets better as you move | Train as planned |
| Clearly sore, but can move normally | Train with less effort, or other body parts |
| Very sore, movement is restricted | Rest that area, go for a walk |
| Sharp or one-sided pain, or joint pain | Stop that exercise and get it checked if it continues |
| Severe pain, swelling, weakness or dark urine | Get medical advice promptly |
This is a practical guide from us, and it does not replace medical advice.
What the evidence says about training through it
The review offers some useful guidance. It says exercise is the most effective means of easing the pain of DOMS, though the relief is temporary. It also says that people who must train daily should reduce the intensity and duration of exercise for 1 to 2 days following exercise that causes intense soreness, or exercise less affected body parts.
There is a reason for care. DOMS can reduce your range of motion and peak force, and it may alter how your muscles work together, which could put extra stress on ligaments and tendons. The review warns that these changes may increase your risk of further injury if you return to hard training too early.
So there is a clear middle ground. Do not sit on the sofa out of fear, and do not grind out a heavy session on legs that can barely straighten.
What to do instead on a sore day
If your legs are sore and you were meant to train legs, you have options:
- Train something else. If your legs are the problem, do your upper body, with exercises such as Push-ups, Band rows and Plank. If your arms are sore, try Glute bridges and Reverse lunges.
- Do a lighter version. Reduce your sets and reps by about half, and use an easier variation.
- Move gently. A walk or easy cycle can loosen you up. Our guide to rest days has more ideas.
- Warm up for longer. Soreness often eases as you get moving. The NHS warm-up routine is a good start.
Then decide after your warm-up. If you feel better, carry on. If it feels worse, stop.
Does stretching help?
Unfortunately, not much. A Cochrane review of 12 studies found that stretching before, after, or both did not produce clinically important reductions in soreness in healthy adults. We go through the evidence in our article on stretching after a workout.
An active cool-down did not do much better. A 2018 review found most evidence suggests active cool-downs do not significantly reduce muscle soreness. If stretching or a cool-down feels good, that is a fine reason to do them. Just do not expect them to prevent tomorrow's stiffness.
The soreness review reported varied results for massage, depending on timing and technique, and it found no effect from several other treatments, including cryotherapy and stretching, and that review is from 2003, so treat it as a starting point. Anti-inflammatory medicines had dose-dependent effects in that review, but we would not suggest taking any medicine just for gym soreness. Ask a pharmacist or doctor if you have questions about what is safe for you.
How to not be sore after a workout
You cannot avoid it completely, and you do not need to. But you can reduce it:
- Build up slowly. The review recommends introducing eccentric or new activities progressively over 1 or 2 weeks.
- Start below your limit. Your first sessions should feel too easy. That is a feature.
- Be careful with slow lowering work. Pull-up negatives and slow Squats reps are very useful, but they are a classic cause of big soreness. Start with low numbers.
- Stay consistent. DOMS is most common after breaks and with new activities, so a steady routine keeps surprises to a minimum.
- Change one thing at a time. Adding several new exercises in a single session is a good way to find out what stairs feel like at age 90.
Does soreness mean a good workout?
No. It is a common belief, but soreness is not a reliable measure of how productive your session was. It mainly shows you did something new or unusually hard. As you get used to your routine, you will feel less sore while still making progress. If you chase soreness, you end up doing unfamiliar things all the time, and this goes against the steady approach that progressive training depends on.
So it is better to judge your workouts by your logbook. Did you hit your reps with good form? Did you beat last time, even slightly? Those are far better signs. If you are unsure how to apply this, read our guide to progressive overload.
Soreness versus injury
Knowing the difference matters more than anything else in this article.
| Normal soreness | Possible injury |
|---|---|
| Dull, achy, tender to touch | Sharp, stabbing or sudden |
| Both sides, in the muscle you trained | Often one side, or in a joint or tendon |
| Starts hours later | Started during a rep |
| Peaks after two or three days, then improves | Stays the same or gets worse |
| Eases with light movement | Gets worse with movement |
If it looks more like the right column, stop the exercise, and see a doctor or physiotherapist if it continues.
The rare but serious exception
Extreme exercise, especially when someone is new or returning to hard training, can very occasionally lead to rhabdomyolysis, a breakdown of muscle tissue that releases substances into the blood that can damage the kidneys. According to MedlinePlus, symptoms can include dark, red or cola-colored urine, decreased urine output, general weakness, and muscle stiffness, aching or tenderness. If you have these symptoms, contact a medical professional right away. Do not wait to see if it passes.
This is not meant to scare you. Ordinary soreness is normal. It is one more reason for building up gradually.
How MuscleUp handles sore weeks
After each session in MuscleUp, you rate it Too easy, Just right or Too hard. If you hit your target and mark it Too hard, the target stays. A first miss changes nothing, so one sore day will not knock back your plan. Two misses in a row bring the target down.
If you are too sore for your workout today, you can move it to tomorrow or replan the rest of your week. And on rest days, short focus sessions, including stretching, are available if you want to move a little. Pain is different, of course. No app should talk you through that, and you should stop and get proper advice.
Three levels, three answers
Mild soreness: go ahead. Clear soreness: go lighter, or train something else. Serious, sharp or strange pain: stop and ask a professional. As your body gets used to your training, soreness will usually bother you much less. Getting past those first couple of weeks is often the hardest part.
